doesn't resolve the question but presents it well
Also comments here: https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/highlights-from-the-comments-on-vibecession
Also note that the Gallup measure doesn't put vibes as that bad. Like 2012 levels rn. But a recent short trough almost as low as 2008
Things I think are compelling explanations:
- there was a genuine decrease in real wages, and sentiment just lags this a bit? Especially if it's not about instantaneous derivative, but whether you're below your lifetime peak income/wealth or not -- and we just now finally caught back up to the 2019 peak
- normal/expected basket of goods has expanded (esp travel). Doesn't explain narrow vibecession but yes downward trend
- people get rejected more than ever these days because we apply to more things than ever (jobs, schools, dating apps, etc). Doesn't explain narrow vibecession but yes downward trend
- people were sad because covid and overall mood colors everything else. (Or because of the media outrage machine or your other favorite explanation for why people are more sad right now.) This sounds hand wavy but even which political party is in power significantly affects how good you think the economy is, so certainly other orthogonal life/world satisfaction factors could as well
- income inequality is up and maybe hits harder in a social media era, and everyone's evaluation of their personal situation is relative to their most successful friend/influencer. (Also not narrow timing)
I think he weighs the "people in China complain the same way but they have insane GDP per capia growth" too heavily. My impression is that the Chinese economy used to be roaring but genuinely has been a bit of a mess in the last ~5 years
(update: confirmed in the followup post)