even religions are often more about identity/tribe than beliefs
(e.g. suni and shia mostly believe all the same stuff but hate each other)
a counterargument to the thesis here: sometimes there are two flags/groups which differ only on one small thing, but then selection effects compound over time and the two groups are now very ideologically different despite the original similar flags still being the rallying symbols
(as opposed to their proposed arc, which is tribes get diluted over time as they grow, and end up similar to their neighbors in everything but how they identify)
I think reality is probably close to 50-50 between these. both are very strong and real. my peers really do have notably different values, but also people are really tribal. maybe 30-70 once you account for the fact that values are partially a function of your social circle (aka tribe)